Aug. 14, 2025
Women Over 40 SHOULD wear Makeup : The Brothers are Probed by Their Producer
Hold tight and please contain your OUTRAGE until the end. Put your THOUGHTS in the COMMENTS
This is the follow-up to Episode 1 of Not So Christian Brothers, and this time, the spotlight turns inward. Rebecca Horan, our no-nonsense producer, grabs the mic and grabs control, dragging Justin and Colm back into the studio to answer for their crimes (verbal and otherwise).
What starts as a behind-the-scenes breakdown quickly spirals into:
• Why Colm thinks women over 40 should wear makeup (yes, he doubles down)
• How he once looked like Bill Gates — and somehow sees this as a good thing
• Why Justin wants to be adopted by Matthew's older brother
• And who really gave the best advice in their debut as Ireland’s most chaotic agony uncles
Expect ruthless questioning, unsolicited opinions, and the occasional existential crisis.
Did Colm go too far? Is Justin just a mindfulness mercenary in disguise? And will Rebecca stay on the show after this one?
🔎 Listen, laugh, and squirm along as The Aftershow Probe gets under the skin of Episode 1.
🎧 Subscribe now so you don’t miss the next probe… or cancellation notice.
#NotSoChristianBrothers #TheAftershowProbe #PodcastFollowUp #ColmHayes #JustinCaffrey #GenXvsBoomer #RebeccaHoran #IrishPodcast #ComedyPodcast #PodcastClips #SiblingDrama #AgonyUncles #HighPerformanceMeetsHighChaos #IrishHumour #PodcastReaction #MakeupGate #UnfilteredChat #MindfulnessVsMayhem #ChristianBrothers
This is the follow-up to Episode 1 of Not So Christian Brothers, and this time, the spotlight turns inward. Rebecca Horan, our no-nonsense producer, grabs the mic and grabs control, dragging Justin and Colm back into the studio to answer for their crimes (verbal and otherwise).
What starts as a behind-the-scenes breakdown quickly spirals into:
• Why Colm thinks women over 40 should wear makeup (yes, he doubles down)
• How he once looked like Bill Gates — and somehow sees this as a good thing
• Why Justin wants to be adopted by Matthew's older brother
• And who really gave the best advice in their debut as Ireland’s most chaotic agony uncles
Expect ruthless questioning, unsolicited opinions, and the occasional existential crisis.
Did Colm go too far? Is Justin just a mindfulness mercenary in disguise? And will Rebecca stay on the show after this one?
🔎 Listen, laugh, and squirm along as The Aftershow Probe gets under the skin of Episode 1.
🎧 Subscribe now so you don’t miss the next probe… or cancellation notice.
#NotSoChristianBrothers #TheAftershowProbe #PodcastFollowUp #ColmHayes #JustinCaffrey #GenXvsBoomer #RebeccaHoran #IrishPodcast #ComedyPodcast #PodcastClips #SiblingDrama #AgonyUncles #HighPerformanceMeetsHighChaos #IrishHumour #PodcastReaction #MakeupGate #UnfilteredChat #MindfulnessVsMayhem #ChristianBrothers
