Click On The 🎤︎︎ (bottom right) To Send Us Your Problems
Not So Christian BrothersNot So Christian Brothers
  • Home
  • Leave a Review
  • Contact
  • Videos
  • Episodes
    Season 118Season 210Season 325Season 418Season 514Season 619Season 72All Episodes115
  • Follow
    Spotify podcast player iconSpotify
  • Search
Follow
Spotify podcast player iconSpotify
Search

Podcast for Men: Real Talk and Honest Chats. #comedypodcast #mensmentalhealth

email capture banner
Join the list and get the latest and exclusibe updates!
Join 10,000 other listeners and get updates on new episodes.
Email has been submitted.
By signing up, you agree to receive email from this podcast.
Please complete the reCAPTCHA verification

Listen On

Spotify podcast player logo

Recent Episodes

  • The Big Hairy Gorilla Dilemma: Shaving, Style Mishaps & The Black Shoe Rule
  • We Are Leaving Ireland: The Warm Climate Move & The Male Vanity Industry
  • The Roy Keane DM & The Tree-Hanging Poo Bag Menace
  • The 17-Minute Leak: A Double Life Exposed & The Bouncy Castle Mayhem
  • The €500 Bet: Sibling Rivalry & The Ring of Kerry Mystery
  • The 50-Year Secret: Surviving the "Dark Knight" & The Ancestry Mystery
  • The "Serial Licker" Files & The Human-AI Job Flip 🐸 | The Truth About The End
  • $200 Million for a Podcast?! 🎙️ | The Truth About Office "Dirty Talk" & Celebrity Secrets
  • The Private School Secret: Why Our Sisters Got the VIP Treatment
  • See all →
Not So Christian Brothers Logo

The Conversations Men Should Be Having, But Don’t

New episodes every Thurs — 30 mins | Aftershow every Sat

All shows drop at 6:00 AM (UK & Irish) / 11:00 AM (Eastern)

Justin Caffrey and Colm Hayes (yes, that’s a stage name) are brothers separated by a 14-year age gap — Hayes is a Baby Boomer, Caffrey is Gen X.

One’s a teetotaller who once lived with monks; the other is a walking vineyard who thinks monks are only good for their wine. One believes in God; the other believes only in ratings.

This gap is profound. Different ages mean different parents — not literally. Hayes holds a nostalgic view of childhood, while Caffrey sees it in a much darker shade of grey.

Every Thursday’s 30-minute episode tackles a big topic or burning listener DM with zero filter and maximum banter.

Then, every Saturday in the Aftershow, they take listeners behind the curtain — unpacking Thursdays show with Rebecca Horan.

  • Leave a Review
  • Contact
  • Videos
  • Episodes
  • © Copyright © 2025 Not So Christian Brothers. All rights reserved. This website, its design, content, audio, video, and related materials are the property of Justin Caffrey Global Limited.
  • Podcast Website by Podpage
Podpage Voice Mail Mic Icon
Don't be afraid to reach out.
You can leave us a voice note with a problem you would like us to solve, or just feedback on the show. Or, even ask us to cover specific topics.

This is your show, so please speak up.

You can also ask for FULL Anonymity when leaving a voice note. Or, we can play your Voice Note if you are up for it? Thx, Colm & Justin

By recording, you consent to being recorded and to your message being stored, edited, and publicly used by this podcast.Voicemail Terms

Start Recording
You are recording
We are recording. You can record a message up to 60 seconds.
00:00
Start OverStop Recording
Microphone Access Required

To record a voicemail, please turn on microphone access for this site in your browser.

Here are instructions forChrome,Safari,and Firefox.

Go Back
Preview and Send
Review your recording and send it to Not So Christian Brothers.
You might get a reply at this email address.

We will only play this on the show with your permission. So please confirm you are happy for us to use your voice. Names will be kept Anonymous unless you tell us we can use your name on the show.

Re-Record
Reset?
Delete this recording and start over?
YesNo
Sent!

Thank you for sending a voicemail!

Close
Powered by Podpage