The episode opens with chaos: Colm reveals that the podcast has received a brand-new solicitor’s letter from the Christian Brothers, threatening legal action if they don’t respond within 14 days. The crew break down why they’ve been targeted again, the déjà vu of the first time they were forced to…
In this week’s Not So Christian Brothers Aftershow, the gang dive into the films that shaped their childhoods, broke their hearts, and still follow them into adulthood. From Justin’s dinosaur-induced panic at 4am, to Colm’s emotional connection with Elf and war epics, to Rebecca’s life-altering moment watching Steel Magnolias, this…
This week on Not So Christian Brothers, Justin, Colm & Rebecca ask the real questions: why were Disney films so dark, and why do the stories that shaped our childhoods still mess with our adult brains? From Snow White’s sketchy plot to Elf’s accidental wisdom, it’s part comedy, part therapy,…
Everyone’s talking about “finding balance.” We’re calling bullsh*t. In this week’s Aftershow, Colm Hayes, Justin Caffrey, and Rebecca Horan tear apart the myth that peace equals success. From meditation disasters to modern burnout, this is Not So Christian Brothers at their funniest and most honest. 💬 In this one: The…
Let’s face it — nobody’s actually “authentic.” In this week’s Not So Christian Brothers Podcast, Colm Hayes, Justin Caffrey, and Rebecca Horan rip apart the illusion of modern honesty. From filtered lives to fake humility, they call out the bullsh*t of pretending everything’s fine. 💬 In this one: Why “authentic”…
What happens when you stop laughing about your childhood — and start telling the truth? This week’s Aftershow gets deep. Colm and Justin revisit their childhood, old guilt, and the snowman story that’s haunted them for decades — while Rebecca digs into the emotional mess underneath. 💬 In this one:…
Are we healing — or just performing pain for attention? This week, Colm Hayes, Justin Caffrey, and Rebecca Horan dive headfirst into the chaos of modern misery culture. From crying selfies and mental health influencers to therapy addiction and Irish repression, nothing’s off limits. 💬 In this episode: Why we…
The Sunday Aftershow goes straight to hell (again). Colm, Justin & Rebecca rip into the Beckhams, Epstein, and why money, power & sex always ruin everything. There’s confession, confrontation, and more inappropriate honesty than any priest could handle. 💥 In this episode: David Beckham’s roast dinner & dirty secrets Rebecca…
From “are you a lesbian, Colm?” to Putin, woke wars, and aliens giving up on humanity — this episode of Not So Christian Brothers is pure chaos in HD. 💬 They cover it all: The rise of angry men & the collapse of “woke” culture Why golf wives are getting…
Can forgiveness really set you free — or is anger the fuel that gets you out of bed? In this explosive Aftershow from Not So Christian Brothers, Colm Hayes, Justin Caffrey, and Rebecca Horan dive deeper into the Thursday episode’s chaos on forgiveness and fury. 🔥 Expect outrageous honesty, dark…
🔥 NEW EPISODE LIVE! 🔥 This week, the boys go head-to-head on one of the toughest topics out there — FORGIVENESS. 😤 Colm says: it’s impossible to forgive. 🧘♂️ Justin says: forgiveness is a superpower — it frees your mind, calms your body, and unlocks your vagus nerve. When you…
What does forgiveness really mean — and is it even possible? In this explosive episode of Not So Christian Brothers, Colm Hayes and Justin Caffrey lock horns over the big moral questions: from Olympic doping scandals and Viagra sponsorships to religion, trauma, and forgiving the unforgivable. Joined by Rebecca (trying…
In this week’s Aftershow, the Not So Christian Brothers — Colm, Justin, and Rebecca — dive deep (and laugh hard) about happiness, grief, guilt, and intrusive thoughts. From Taylor Swift’s controversial new album to the realities of loss, guilt when life feels good again, and the magic of being present,…
Ever wake up at 3 a.m. replaying every bad decision you’ve ever made? Justin Caffrey and Colm Hayes get brutally honest about overthinking, sleepless nights, and the voices in your head that won’t shut up. In this episode of Not So Christian Brothers, the trio dive into intrusive thoughts, anxiety,…
After opening up about losing his wife of 35 years, Colm returns with Justin and Rebecca for the Not So Christian Brothers Aftershow. The brothers reflect on grief, therapy, and the journey of rebuilding connection — with humour, honesty, and heart. Justin shares why a therapist once told him he…
This episode is a special one. Justin welcomes his brother Colm back to the studio after the heartbreaking loss of his wife Anne. What follows is one of the most raw and powerful conversations we’ve ever had on Not So Christian Brothers. Colm speaks with honesty about love, loss, and…
Irish funerals are like nothing else in the world. 🇮🇪 In this Aftershow of Not So Christian Brothers, Rebecca, Justin, and Beatrice dive into the unique Irish tradition of remembering loved ones through four simple objects. From blankets and dog leads to football boots and coffee cups, these symbols capture…
This week’s episode of Not So Christian Brothers begins with a heavy heart. Justin's brother and co-host Colm lost his wife, Anne, last week after a long and courageous battle with cancer. Our thoughts and prayers are with Colm and his children, Alex and Holly. We hope to have him…
Childhood labels, hidden trauma, and the question of destiny — are we shaped by nature, nurture, or the stories we tell ourselves? Are we born to succeed or fail… or can we change the script? ❤️ Note to Listeners Before we dive in, we want to pause. Colm’s beautiful wife…
This week’s Not So Christian Brothers Aftershow looks a little different… with Colm away and Terry missing in action, Rebecca and Beatrice take over the mic — with Justin looking on nervously in the corner. Following Beatrice’s special episode, the Aftershow dives into: - 20 years of marriage — what…
Do men really share the load at home? Or do old roles still rule modern marriages? In this Not So Christian Brothers special, Beatrice Caffrey steps in for Colm (away on personal matters) and Rebecca (on holiday) to join her husband, Justin Caffrey, for an unfiltered conversation about marriage, masculinity,…
But just when you think it’s all laughs, Rebecca shares a harrowing personal story from her holiday (Caution When Listening), witnessing a man collapse and die on the beach in front of his wife and children. The conversation turns raw, heartbreaking, and deeply human. This Aftershow is pure chaos —…
A mic dies mid-show, Justin rushes his son to A&E, Colm relives a live-radio disaster, and Rebecca serves a DM about the friend who never, ever pays. From a Chris Evans moment at CarFest to a debate on control (do we have any?), this episode is messy, honest, and very…