Everybody’s Faking It (Even You)
From Instagram saints to middle-aged disasters — Colm, Justin & Rebecca call out the great modern lie: pretending you’ve got it all together.
Let’s be honest — we’re all full of sh*t.
This week, the Not So Christian Brothers — Colm Hayes, Justin Caffrey, and Rebecca Horan — rip apart the illusion of perfection we’ve built online and off.
From filtered lives and fake humility to Irish denial, ego, and middle-aged crisis rebrands, they say the quiet part out loud.
Colm calls out “bullsh*t wellness,” Justin admits he’s been just as guilty, and Rebecca lays down the truth about people who post “authentic” just to get attention.
It’s funny, uncomfortable, and scarily relatable — a full-on takedown of modern self-delusion.
🎙 New shows every Thursday & Sunday — subscribe now and join the unholy honesty.
You think you’re being real? You’re not — and neither are we.
This episode of Not So Christian Brothers goes straight for the jugular:
why everyone’s pretending, who’s fooling who, and how social media made us all addicted to lying.
It’s fast, filthy, and full of uncomfortable truth.
If you’ve ever posted a “no filter” selfie or humble-bragged about mindfulness — you might want to sit this one out.
⏱️ Chapter Timings
00:00 – Welcome & Colm’s rant on fake people
03:00 – The cult of “authentic” influencers
06:00 – Justin admits he’s played the same game
09:00 – Rebecca’s reality check: “Nobody’s that happy”
12:00 – The Irish art of denial
15:00 – Midlife rebrands & spiritual bullshit
18:00 – Truth bombs & uncomfortable laughter
21:00 – Sunday tease & a final jab at fake gratitude
🗓 Release Date: Thursday, 6 November 2025
🎙 Next Episode: Sunday, 9 November 2025
📢 New shows every Thursday & Sunday — on Spotify, Acast, Apple, and YouTube.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
